Protest “Inhuman Policies” & “Imperialistic Plots”
Arash Norouzi The Mossadegh Project | November 7, 2017 |
Early in the Iran hostage crisis, anti-Shah Iranian students in the Philippines’ capital city demonstrated in support of Ayatollah Ruhollah Khomeini and the revolutionaries who seized the U.S. Embassy in Tehran 9 days earlier. A two-day hunger strike followed.
The U.S. Embassy in Manila transmitted the written demands of the protesters to Sec. of State Cyrus Vance, per James D. Rosenthal, Deputy Chief of Mission in Manila from 1979-1982. The first two messages were also copied to the American Consulate in Hong Kong.
The final telegram is from the U.S. Ambassador to the Philippines, Richard W. Murphy, who had discussed with President Marcos the growing security concerns both within the country and of Filipinos living and working in Iran.
U.S. Embassy in Manila, Philippines to Secretary of State (Cyrus Vance)
Demonstration of Iranian
Students In Manila
UNCLASSIFIED
PAGE 01 MANILA 21606 130926Z
ACTION SY-05
INFO OCT-01 EA-12 ADS-00 SYE-00 PM-06 SP-02 SS-15
CIAE-00 DODE-00 INR-10 NSAE-00 PA-02 NSCE-00
SSO-00 ICAE-00 INRE-00 OC-06 CCO-00 NEA-07 HA-05
/071 W
------------------044234 130929Z /21
O 130910Z NOV 79
FM AMEMBASSY MANILA
TO SECSTATE WASHDC IMMEDIATE 2134
INFO AMCONSUL HONG KONG PRIORITY
UNCLAS MANILA 21606
DEPT FOR A/SY/OPS/FO, A/SY/CC
HONG KONG FOR RSS, RMO
E.O. 12065: N/A
TAGS: ASEC
SUBJECT: DEMONSTRATION BY IRANIAN STUDENTS IN MANILA -
- NOVEMBER 13, 1979
REF: MANILA 21544
1. RSO PERSONNEL [Regional Security Officer] WHO WITNESSED DEMONSTRATION OF IRANIAN
STUDENTS AT IRANIAN EMBASSY IN MAKATI, METRO MANILA,
OBTAINED A COPY OF A HANDOUT WHICH WAS BEING DISTRIBUTED
BY IRANIAN DEMONSTRATORS.
2. TITLE: "OUR QUESTIONS AND DEMANDS" BY IRANIAN MUSLIM
STUDENTS IN THE PHILIPPINES.
BEGIN TEXT: QUOTE WE ARE RESPECTING ALL LIBERAL AND
FREEDOM-LOVING PEOPLE OF THE WORLD, INCLUDING THAT OF THE
UNITED STATES. BUT WE WOULD LIKE TO ASK SOME QUESTIONS
FROM THE IMPERIALIST POLICY MAKERS IN AMERICA:
1. O, MR. CARTER, YOU ALWAYS HAVE CLAIMED THAT YOU ARE A
STRONG SUPPORTER OF THE HUMAN RIGHTS ALL OVER THE WORLD,
THEN WHY DID YOU SUPPORT
THE SHAH
DURING THE REVOLUTION;
WHEN HE MASSACRED THOUSANDS OF INNOCENT DEMONSTRATORS IN
IRAN? WHY ARE YOU NOW PROTECTING THAT TREACHEROUS MAN WHO
IS ONE OF THE WORST VIOLATORS OF HUMAN RIGHTS IN THE HISTORY?
2. O, U.S. POLICY MAKERS, WHY DID YOU PLOT THE COUP
D'ETAT OF MORDAD 28, 1953 DURING WHICH YOU TOPPLED IRAN'S
NATIONALIST LEADER DR. MOHAMMAD MOSADDEQ AND BROUGHT THE
PUPPET SHAH TO POWER, AGAINST THE WILL OF OUR PEOPLE?
[Premier Mossadegh, overthrown in an Aug. 1953 CIA coup]
3. O, LIBERAL MINDED AMERICANS* ARE THESE INHUMAN
POLICIES OF THE US GOVERNMENT IN MAKING IMPERIALISTIC
PLOTS AGAINST THE OTHER PEOPLE OF THE WORLD AND MASTER
MINDING ALL COUP D'ETATS, ECONOMIC EXPLOITATIONS OF THE
PEOPLE OF THE WORLD AND COUNTLESS ABUSED BY THAT GOVERNMENT,
ACCEPTED AND SUPPORTED BY YOU?
IF NOT, THEN HOW DO YOU VOTE FOR THEM AND PUT THEM IN
THE OFFICE? WHY DO NOT YOU PROTEST? REMOVE THEM FROM
THE OFFICE*
- AND NOW OUR DEMANDS
WE ARE SUPPORTING THE MUSLIM STUDENTS IN TEHRAN WHO
HAVE TAKEN OVER THE US EMBASSY, THE ESPIONAGE CENTER,
AND THE HOSTAGES (MOST OF THEM SPIES AND CIA AGENTS)
AND WE STRONGLY SUPPORT AYATOLLAH KHOMEINI AND THE
ISLAMIC REPUBLIC. WE ALSO DEMAND THAT:
1. THE ISLAMIC REPUBLIC AND THE PEOPLE OF IRAN SHOULD
STAND FIRMLY AGAINST THE US GOVERNMENT TO PROVE TO ALL
PERSECUTED PEOPLE OF THE WORLD THAT: 'THE SUPER POWERS
ARE NOT BUT THE PAPER TIGERS* AND IF THEY SEEM TO BE
STRONG, IT IS BECAUSE WE HAVE SHOWN OURSELVES WEAK*'
2. WE ASK THE US GOVERNMENT TO HAND OVER THE CRIMINAL
SHAH, TO THE PEOPLE OF IRAN. SHE SHOULD NOT PROTECT OR
SUPPORT THAT TREACHEROUS PERSON UNDER THE COVER OR
'CANCER" OF ANY OTHER BASELESS EXCUSE.
THE US GOVERNMENT SHOULD NOT FORGET THAT IT IS NOT
FACING A GOVERNMENT BUT THE PEOPLE OF IRAN, AND OUR
PEOPLE WILL NOT GIVE UP THEIR DEMANDS UNTIL THEY WILL
ACHIEVE THEIR GOAL*
3. WE ASK ALL PERSECUTED MASSES OF THE WORLD TO UNITE
THEMSELVES AGAINST THE IMPERIALIST POWERS. THEY SHOULD
NOT BE MISGUIDED BY THE PRESS OR PROPAGANDA OF THE SUPER
POWERS AGAINST THE LIBERATION MOVEMENTS OF THE EXPLOITED
MASSES OF THE WORLD AND PARTICULARLY THAT OF IRANIAN
PEOPLE.
VIVA LIBERTY AND INDEPENDENCE MOVEMENTS OF ALL EXPLOITED
PEOPLES AND NATIONS DF THE WORLD*
DOWN WITH THE IMPERIALISM, OF ANY TYPE IT MAYBE* LONG
LIVE ISLAMIC REPUBLIC OF IRAN* DEATH TO THE US IMPERIALISM*
UNQUOTE. END TEXT. ROSENTHAL [James D. Rosenthal, DCM]
UNCLASSIFIED
U.S. Embassy in Manila, Philippines to Secretary of State (Cyrus Vance)
Demonstration of Iranian
Students In Manila
UNCLASSIFIED
PAGE 01 MANILA 21695 140757Z
ACTION SY-05
INFO OCT-01 EA-12 ADS-00 SYE-00 NEA-07 MCT-02 PM-06
SP-02 SS-15 CIAE-00 DODE-00 INR-10 NSAE-00 PA-02
NSCE-00 SSO-00 ICAE-00 INRE-00 /062 W
------------------051479 140758Z /21
O 140743Z NOV 79
FM AMEMBASSY MANILA
TO SECSTATE WASHDC IMMEDIATE 2192
INFO AMCONSUL HONG KONG PRIORITY
UNCLAS MANILA 21695
DEPT FOR A/SY/OPS/FO, A/SY/CC
HONG KONG FOR RSS, RMO
E.O. 12065: N/A
TAGS: ASEC
SUBJECT: DEMONSTRATION BY IRANIAN STUDENTS IN MANILA
- NOVEMBER 14, 1979
1. AT APPROXIMATELY 1000 (LOCAL) 11/14/79 SOME TWENTY
(20) IRANIAN STUDENTS GATHERED AT IRANIAN EMBASSY IN
MAKATI, METRO MANILA. ALL REPORTS INDICATE THAT DEMONSTRATION
WAS PEACEFUL AND CONSISTED OF PASSING OUT
LEAFLETS.
2. RSO PERSONNEL OBTAINED COPY OF TODAY'S HANDOUT.
TITLE: "OUR HUNGER STRIKE, COMMUNIQUE NO. 2" IRANIAN
STUDENTS IN THE PHILIPPINES.
BEGIN TEXT. QUOTE AFTER THE SUCCESSFUL DEMONSTRATION
WHICH WAS HELD IN MAKATI METRO MANILA, WE HAVE DECIDED TO
HAVE A HUNGER STRIKE FOR TWO DAYS.
DURING THE DEMONSTRATION THAT WAS ATTENDED BY OVER 1,000
IRANIAN, MALE AND FEMALE STUDENTS, THE PARTICIPANTS PRAYED
IN GROUP AND THEN THEY BURNED THE EFFIGIES OF CARTER AND
SADAT AND LATER ON, THE US FLAG. [Egyptian President Anwar Sadat]
THEY SHOUTED ALLAH-O-AKBAR (GOD IS GREAT), VIVA KHOMEINI,
DOWN WITH CARTER DOWN WITH SADAT AND GIVE SHAH BACK, SHAH
IS A MURDERER, SHAH IS A TORTURER, WE BACK UP THE MUSLIM
STUDENTS HOLDING AMERICAN SPIES, ETC.
AFTER THE DEMONSTRATION WAS OVER, 100 MALE AND FEMALE
STUDENTS DECIDED TO TAKE PART IN TWO-DAY HUNGER STRIKE,
STARTING FROM 2 P.M. TUESDAY NOVEMBER 13, 1979.
WE HAVE DECIDED TO SHOW OUR SOLIDARITY WITH ALL IRANIAN
BROTHERS AND SISTERS IN TEHRAN, INDIA,
TURKEY, EUROPE AND US. WE SHALL FAST AS THEY ARE DOING.
OUR OBJECTIVES ARE:
(1) TO CONDEMN ALL IMPERIALIST ACTIVITIES BY ALL SUPER
POWERS AND PARTICULARLY AMERICA. (2) WE WANT SHAH TO BE
GIVEN BACK TO THE IRANIAN PEOPLE TO STAND FOR TRIAL AND
ANSWER THE CHARGES OF TREASON AND MURDER OF AROUND
100,000 PEOPLE DURING HIS REIGN AND JAILING AND EXILING
THE INTELLECTUALS AND HUNDREDS OF THOUSAND OF ACTIVIST
PEOPLE OF IRAN. (3) WE SUPPORT THE STUDENTS WHO HAVE
BRAVELY CONQUERED THE US EMBASSY (THE ESPIONAGE CENTER)
IN IRAN AND WE WANT THEM TO GO ON UNTIL THE VICTORY IS
ACHIEVED.
LONG LIVE THE LIBERATION MOVEMENT OF THE IRANIAN PEOPLE
AND ALL PERSECUTED PEOPLE OF THE WORLD. DOWN WITH THE
IMPERIALISM AND HEGEMONISM OF THE SUPER POWERS LED BY
U.S. LONG LIVE IMAM KHOMEINI, THE SUPPORTER OF ALL
PERSECUTED PEOPLE OF THE WORLD. UNQUOTE. END TEXT.
ROSENTHAL
UNCLASSIFIED
U.S. Embassy in Manila, Philippines to Secretary of State (Cyrus Vance)
Iranian Student Activities In Manila
CONFIDENTIAL
PAGE 01 MANILA 22153 200947Z
ACTION SY-05
INFO OCT-01 EA-10 ADS-00 SYE-00 NEA-06 MCT-02 PM-06
SP-02 SS-15 CIAE-00 DODE-00 INR-10 NSAE-00 PA-01
NSCE-00 SSO-00 ICAE-00 INRE-00 /058 W
------------------095130 201050Z /17
P 200914Z NOV 79
FM AMEMBASSY MANILA
TO SECSTATE WASHDC PRIORITY 2511
C O N F I D E N T I A L MANILA 22153
E.O. 12065: GDS 11/20/85 (MALIN, HERBERT S.) OR/P
TAGS: PINS, POR, ASEC, IR, RP
SUBJECT: (U) IRANIAN STUDENT ACTIVITIES IN MANILA
REF: (A) MANILA 21953, (B) MANILA 21858, (C) MANILA 21856,
- (D) MANILA 21672, (E) MANILA 21695, (F) MANILA 21419
1. (C) SINCE NOVEMBER 13 AND 14 DEMONSTRATION BY
IRANIAN STUDENTS (REFTEL D AND E) AND 48-HOUR HUNGER
STRIKE AT THEIR EMBASSY, IRANIAN STUDENTS HAVE BEEN
QUIET. THEY CONTINUE TO MEET PRIVATELY, PRESUMABLY TO
FOLLOW EVENTS AND PRAY. AT SAME TIME THERE ARE
UNCONFIRMED REPORTS THAT THE IRANIAN EMBASSY, WHICH
PUBLICLY SUPPORTED LAST WEEK'S DEMONSTRATIONS, HAD
THREATENED TO CUT ECONOMIC ASSISTANCE TO STUDENTS WHO
DID NOT PARTICIPATE IN ANTI-US ACTIVITIES. HOWEVER,
PUBLIC COMMITMENTS OF PRESIDENT MARCOS AND DEFMIN ENRILE
TO ARREST AND DEPORT ANY FOREIGNER ENGAGING IN
UNAUTHORIZED DEMONSTRATIONS SEEM TO HAVE MADE THEIR
POINT WITH IRANIANS. [Filipino President Ferdinand Marcos and Defense Minister Juan Ponce Enrile]
2. (C) AMERICAN STUDENTS AT LOCAL UNIVERSITIES REPORT
THAT IRANIAN CLASSMATES HAVE NOT SOUGHT THEM OUT. SO
FAR NOVEMBER 8 ASSAULT ON TWO MARINE SECURITY GUARDS
(REFTEL F) APPEARS TO BE ISOLATED INCIDENT.
3. (C) LOCAL POLICE CONTINUE TO MONITOR ACTIVITIES OF
IRANIAN STUDENTS AND TO MAINTAIN CLOSE LIAISON WITH RSO.
4. (C) PHILIPPINE GOVERNMENT HAS DENIED REQUEST OF SOME
IRANIANS TO ENROLL IN MINDANAO STATE UNIVERSITY AT
MARAWI CITY. PRESUMPTION BEHIND THIS PROHIBITION IS THAT
IRANIANS MAY BE THINKING ABOUT CONTACTS WITH MNLF. [Moro National Liberation Front]
5. (U) MEDIA CONTINUE TO HIGHLIGHT DEVELOPMENTS IN
TEHRAN AND WASHINGTON. THE RELATIVELY FEW EDITORIAL
COMMENTS AGREE THAT THE HOSTAGE TAKING IS INEXCUSABLE,
BUT ARE NOW ATTEMPTING A DEEPER ANALYSIS OF THE REASONS
BEHIND IT. INTER ALIA, SOME COMMENTATORS CITE YEARS OF
"OPPRESSION" UNDER THE SHAH AND IRANIAN FEARS THAT THE
US SUPPORTS HIS RETURN. BACKGROUND STORIES ABOUT THE
SHAH'S RULE AND WEALTH HAVE ALSO APPEARED.
6. (C) ACCORDING TO FOREIGN MINISTRY, SITUATION AT
PHILIPPINE EMBASSY IN TEHRAN IS DESCRIBED AS NORMAL
ALTHOUGH THERE HAVE BEEN LARGE NUMBERS OF IRANIAN
STUDENTS "MILLING AROUND" -- APPLYING FOR VISAS AS THEY
HAVE FOR THE PAST 4-6 WEEKS. GOP CONTINGENCY PLANS
EXIST TO EVACUATE THE 1,000 PLUS PRIVATE FILIPINOS IN
IRAN TO PAKISTAN. [Government of the Philippines]
THE MAJORITY OF THESE WORK FOR IRAN AIR OR PAGE COMMUNICATION COMPANY. ROSENTHAL
CONFIDENTIAL
U.S. Embassy in Manila, Philippines to Secretary of State (Cyrus Vance)
Appeal To Student Groups: Hostages
CONFIDENTIAL
PAGE 01 MANILA 22159 211857Z
ACTION SS-30
INFO OCT-01 ADS-00 SSO-00 /031 W
------------------106031 211914Z /42
O 200942Z NOV 79
FM AMEMBASSY MANILA
TO SECSTATE WASHDC IMMEDIATE 2515
INFO USICA WASHDC
C O N F I D E N T I A L MANILA 22159
EXDIS, FOR NEA/IRN WORKING GROUP; USICA FOR NEA
C O R R E C T E D C O P Y (TEXT - PARA 4 TO END)
E.O. 12065: GDS 11/20/85 (KEOGH, WILLIAM H.) OR-O
TAGS: PINS, IR, US, RP
SUBJECT: APPEAL TO STUDENT GROUPS: HOSTAGES
REF: STATE 300924
1. (C-ENTIRE TEXT).
2. AFTER YEARS OF MARTIAL LAW, STUDENT GROUPS IN THE
PHILIPPINES ARE FRAGMENTED, EPHEMERAL, NEITHER WELLORGANIZED
NOR PARTICULARLY INFLUENTIAL, EVEN ON CAMPUS.
TO THE EXTENT THAT THEY HOLD DEFINABLE POLITICAL OPINIONS,
THESE GROUPS OPPOSE THE MARCOS GOVERNMENT AND, BECAUSE
THEY THINK THE U.S. IS A MAIN SUPPORTER AND BENEFACTOR
OF MARCOS, ARE GENERALLY HOSTILE TO U.S. ACTIONS AND
POLICIES. THEREFORE, IT IS VERY UNLIKELY THAT ANY
ORGANIZED STUDENT GROUPS COULD BE PERSUADED TO DO ANYTHING
PUBLICLY IN SUPPORT OF THE U.S. TO PROPOSE ONE
OR MORE OF THEM DO SO, EVEN ON SUCH A SUBJECT, WOULD
ALMOST CERTAINLY RESULT IN REJECTION, AND POSSIBLY HARMFUL
PUBLICITY. FURTHER, WHILE STUDENT GROUPS MAY NOT BE
ACTUALLY SYMPATHETIC TO THE IRANIAN STUDENTS, THEY WOULD
NOT BE INCLINED TO VIEW THE SITUATION IN TERMS OF
INTERNATIONAL LAW AND DIPLOMATIC CUSTOMS AND PRACTICES,
THE BASIS OF OUR POSITION. IN SHORT, WE SERIOUSLY
DOUBT THAT WE COULD EFFECTIVELY TAKE ACTION AS SUGGESTED
REFTEL, DIRECTLY OR INDIRECTLY.
3. COULD POINT OUT THAT PHILIPPINE GOVERNMENT HAS BEEN
LEERY OF PUBLICLY CRITICIZING IRANIAN ACTIONS FROM START.
PRESENCE OF MORE THAN 3000 POSSIBLY DISRUPTIVE IRANIAN
STUDENTS, MOSTLY IN MANILA, IS ONE FACTOR. THE 17
FILIPINOS STAFFING THE EMBASSY IN TEHRAN IS ANOTHER.
PRESENCE OF 1600 FILIPINO WORKERS IN IRAN IS A THIRD.
BELIEVE APPROACH THROUGH GOVERNMENT-CONTROLLED
YOUTH ORGANIZATIONS WOULD NOT BE ACCEPTABLE, NOR
WOULD GOP VIEW ANY ACTIVITIES CALLING ATTENTION TO
PHILIPPINES AS A CRITIC WITH EQUANIMITY.
4. ABOVE VIEWS REACHED DURING CONSULTATIONS
APPROPRIATE MISSION ELEMENTS, INCLUDING ACTING CHIEF
OF MISSION, WHO CONCURS THIS MESSAGE. IT REPRESENTS
AN IMMEDIATE REACTION. WE WILL BE LOOKING INTO SUBJECT
MORE THOROUGHLY TO SEE IF THERE IS IN FACT ANYTHING
WE CAN DO ON THIS SCORE. WILL REPORT AS APPROPRIATE.
ROSENTHAL
CONFIDENTIAL
U.S. Embassy in Manila, Philippines to Secretary of State (Cyrus Vance)
Security During Iran Crisis
SECRET
PAGE 01 MANILA 22448 260646Z
ACTION SS-30
INFO OCT-01 ADS-00 SSO-00 /031 W
------------------006205 260652Z /14
O 260640Z NOV 79
FM AMEMBASSY MANILA
TO SECSTATE WASHDC IMMEDIATE 2742
S E C R E T MANILA 22448
EXDIS
E.O. 12065: GDS 11/26/85 (MURPHY, RICHARD .)
TAGS: PINS, IR, RP, ASEC
SUBJECT: SECURITY DURING IRAN CRISIS
REF: A) STATE 305379, B) STATE 305427, C) MANILA 22283,
D) MANILA 22413
1. (SECRET-ENTIRE TEXT).
2. I MADE ALL POINTS REF A TO MARCOS IN NOVEMBER 26
MEETING. [President Ferdinand Marcos] EXPRESSED GRATITUDE FOR EXTRA SECURITY
ASSIGNED TO MISSION PREMISES AND OTHER OFFICIAL U.S.
SITES IN MANILA. MARCOS AGREED THAT SECURITY
IMPLICATIONS STEMMING FROM RECENT EVENTS ARE WORRISOME
AND THAT POSSIBIOITY [sic] OF INCIDENTS IN PHILIPPINES CANNOT
BE EXCLUDED GIVEN "PARTICULAR CHARACTER OF OUR MUSLIM
POPULATION." LATTER HE DESCRIBED AS SUNNI BUT SUBJECT
TO EMOTIONAL APPEALS FROM ANY MUSLIM LEADER SUCH AS
KHOMEINI CALLING FOR ACTION IN NAME OF ISLAM.
3. REFS C AND D DETAIL ALL MEASURES TAKEN TO DATE IN
MANILA. I HAVE INSTRUCTED CONSULATE CEBU AND ICA/DAVAO
TO TAKE SIMILAR PRECAUTIONS. WE CONTINUE TO REMAIN IN
CONSTANT TOUCH WITH GOP POLICE [Government of the Philippines] AND OTHER AUTHORITIES,
WHO ARE COOPERATING FULLY. MURPHY [U.S. Ambassador Richard W. Murphy]
Related links:
The President’s Failure In Iran | U.S. Congress, February 15, 1979
Maria A. Ressa, Filipino Journalist (ABS-CBN, CNN): "Blowback in Maguindanao"
Iran Hostage Crisis “Not Their Fault”, Writes Cal Poly Student (Nov. 1979 letter)
MOSSADEGH t-shirts — “If I sit silently, I have sinned”